Delivering Mental Health Care
Through Telemedicine
blog
    

Is Telemental Health treatment really as good as in-person treatment?

 logo.png

 When providers initially consider whether or not to make the transition and begin providing some, or all, of their treatment through a digital delivery method, there is often strong hesitation simply because many fear that the quality of treatment must somehow be diminished. The fear is that since telemedicine is a newer, and alternative, form of treatment, that it is somehow also less effective or remains a less desirable standard of care.

But the truth is that this technology represents much of the future in healthcare, and telemental health especially, will be leading the charge into the next era. Telemental health works particularly well using digital-and especially video-based-care models. This is one of the few health specialties that doesn’t necessarily require ‘touch’ when doing an assessment or delivering treatment. Without that need, the provider does not typically need to be in the same room as the patient.

Another argument that is commonly provided is that somehow, the communication between patient and provider won’t be quite as good as an in-person visit. This may have been true when telehealth was in its infancy and lacked the technological capabilities it currently has. With the recent advancements in videoconferencing systems as well as the ability to access much higher Internet speeds, the quality of video provides an environment in which there is little difference to an in-person consultation. The provider will still be able to pick up on nonverbal cues, as well as observe other factors such as their behaviors, facial expressions, hygiene and their speech patterns.

Despite the assumption that telemental health could potentially lead to a lower standard of care, the opposite has actually been shown in multiple studies. A recent study found that telemental health care is as effective as a standard consultation, and it also greatly increases access to care for many patients who may not otherwise be able to seek treatment. Allowing the patient to seek treatment in their own community, or even in their own home, has led to less travel, fewer absences from work, less time waiting, more choices for treatment and ultimately, better health outcomes. Providers usually have less travel time too, allowing them to see more patients. All of these factors lead to greater access for patients. This is especially important given the huge shortage of providers in this field.

In addition to the data indicating that telemental health is at least as good as an in-person consultation, there is also additional data that supports the idea that with certain patient populations, it may be the superior treatment method. In one study, researchers found that with certain children and adolescents, the video-based care model led to a superior psychiatric assessment than face-to-face consultation. These researchers found four factors to support their view, including: the novelty of the consultation, the capacity to provide direction, the extra psychological and physical distance, and the authenticity of the family interaction.

While the data supports the idea that telemental health programs are as effective, and in certain cases, more effective, than the traditional care model, there is still the question of how the patient perception of their care might impact the efficacy of treatment. It turns out that in this area too, telemental health services are shown to be as effective as face-to-face communication in most settings. A systematic review of studies looking at patient treatment satisfaction and therapeutic alliance found that there were similar results between the two care models.

Providers considering offering telemental health services should familiarize themselves with the research and consider the many ways in which this care model could benefit their patients as well as themselves. Remote telemental health services represent the future of psychiatry and psychology. Visit Brighter Day Health's website today 

 

Apply Today!

Recent Posts